How Brand and Fee Demand Affect Students
College education is often seen as the best way to ensure future career and financial success. However, it comes at a high price that many students and their families cannot afford. The average tuition fee for a four-year college in the US was $36,880 in 2019-2020, according to the College Board. This is more than six times the average inflation rate since 1980.
## Why are college fees so high and what can be done to make them more affordable?
In this article, we will explore how college and tuition monopoly, brand and fee demand affect students and their choices.
What is College and Tuition Monopoly?
A monopoly is a market situation where there is only one seller or provider of a good or service, who can set the price and quantity without any competition. A college and tuition monopoly is when colleges have the power to charge high fees and limit the number of students they admit, without facing any significant competition from other colleges or alternative education options.
There are several factors that contribute to the college and tuition monopoly in the US:
● Government intervention: The federal government subsidizes student loans and grants, which makes college more accessible for low-income students, but also creates an artificial demand for college education. This allows colleges to raise their fees without losing customers, as students can borrow more money to pay for them. The government also regulates the accreditation of colleges, which limits the entry of new and innovative providers of higher education.
● Information asymmetry: Students and their families often lack reliable and transparent information about the quality and outcomes of different colleges and programs. They rely on rankings, reputation, and word-of-mouth to make their decisions, which may not reflect the true value of a college education. Colleges can use their brand name and marketing strategies to attract more applicants and charge higher fees, regardless of their actual performance or quality.
● Lack of price elasticity: Price elasticity is a measure of how sensitive consumers are to changes in price. If consumers are price elastic, they will buy less of a good or service when its price increases, and vice versa. If consumers are price inelastic, they will buy the same amount or more of a good or service when its price increases, and vice versa. College education is generally considered to be price inelastic, as students and their families view it as a necessity and an investment for their future. They are willing to pay more for college education, even if it means taking on more debt or sacrificing other expenses.
● Network effects: Network effects are when the value of a good or service increases as more people use it. College education has positive network effects, as students benefit from being part of a large and diverse community of peers, alumni, faculty, employers, and other stakeholders. Colleges can leverage their network effects to attract more students and charge higher fees, as students value the social capital and opportunities that come with attending a prestigious college.
##How Does Brand and Fee Demand Affect Students?
The college and tuition monopoly has several implications for students and their choices:
● Higher debt burden: Students who attend expensive colleges often have to take on large amounts of debt to finance their education. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, the total outstanding student debt in the US reached $1.7 trillion in 2020, with an average balance of $37,693 per borrower. Student debt can have negative effects on students’ mental health, well-being, career prospects, and life choices.
● Lower return on investment: Students who attend expensive colleges may not get a commensurate return on their investment in terms of income, employment, or satisfaction. According to PayScale, the average annual return on investment (ROI) for a four-year college degree in the US was 8.3% in 2020, but it varied widely depending on the college, major, and career path. Some colleges had negative ROIs, meaning that students would have been better off financially if they had not attended college at all.
● Limited access and diversity: Students who attend expensive colleges tend to come from privileged backgrounds, as they have more resources and opportunities to prepare for and apply to college. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2016, 77% of adults with a bachelor’s degree or higher came from families with incomes above the median income level for their age group. This creates a gap in access and diversity among college students, which can affect their learning outcomes, social interactions, and civic engagement.
##What Can Be Done to Break the College and Tuition Monopoly?
There are several possible solutions to break the college and tuition monopoly and make college education more affordable and accessible for students:
● Reform government policies: The government can reform its policies regarding student loans, grants, accreditation, and regulation to create more competition and transparency in the higher education market. For example, it can cap the amount of loans that students can borrow based on their expected earnings after graduation; it can provide more need-based grants that do not depend on academic merit; it can allow more alternative providers of higher education to enter the market; and it can require colleges to disclose more information about their costs, quality, outcomes
● Promote alternative education options: Students can explore alternative education options that may suit their needs better than traditional four-year colleges. For example, they can enroll in online courses or programs that offer flexible schedules, lower costs, and personalized learning; they can pursue vocational or technical training that prepares them for specific careers or industries; they can join apprenticeships or internships that provide hands-on experience and mentorship; or they can take gap years or travel abroad that expose them to different cultures and perspectives.
● Empower student choice: Students can empower themselves by making informed choices about their college education based on their goals, interests, abilities, valuesConclusion
College education is a valuable and rewarding experience for many students, but it also comes with a high price tag that can limit their choices and opportunities. The college and tuition monopoly is a result of various factors that give colleges the power to charge high fees and limit the number of students they admit, without facing any significant competition from other colleges or alternative education options. This affects students and their families in terms of debt burden, return on investment, access and diversity. To break the college and tuition monopoly and make college education more affordable and accessible for students, there are several possible solutions that involve reforming government policies, promoting alternative education options, and empowering student choice. By doing so, we can create a more diverse, equitable, and innovative higher education system that benefits students and society.
## Conclusion
College education is a valuable and rewarding experience for many students, but it also comes with a high price tag that can limit their choices and opportunities.
The college and tuition monopoly is a result of various factors that give colleges the power to charge high fees and limit the number of students they admit, without facing any significant competition from other colleges or alternative education options.
This affects students and their families in terms of debt burden, return on investment, access and diversity.
To break the college and tuition monopoly and make college education more affordable and accessible for students, there are several possible solutions that involve reforming government policies, promoting alternative education options, and empowering student choice.
By doing so, we can create a more diverse, equitable, and innovative higher education system that benefits students and society.
0 Comments